Posted by: David Offutt | December 11, 2015

GOP Panic Mode and the Dark Side



America and Americans definitely have a dark side.  Our history is laced with hatreds, fears, and prejudices that resulted in acts that embarrass us today – and that’s our saving grace. We try to recognize those errors of judgment and actions so as to not repeat them.


The Native Americans confronted an invasion of English immigrants that resulted in their land being taken from them. The English colonists even paid bounties for Indian scalps. The great Civil War cavalry officer Philip Sheridan said that the only good Indian he ever saw was dead.  The genocide of our original inhabitants haunts us still.


(Click on the photo to enlarge)

(Click on the photo to enlarge)

The peculiar institution of slavery, which contradicted our birthday document written by slave owner Thomas Jefferson, was based on a racism that we still have not entirely conquered even though we elected a black man as President of the United States.  I know several people who have never accepted Barack Obama as their president simply because he’s black. You probably know some, too.


After Pearl Harbor, the hatred of Japan led to the fear of Japanese-Americans – whether naturalized citizens or born in the U.S. With no evidence of treason and no conviction of crimes, they were rounded up, deprived of their professions and property, and placed in internment camps. True, they were not placed in slave labor or extermination camps, but they were interned nevertheless.  And this injustice was approved by one of our three greatest presidents, Franklin Delano Roosevelt.


The spiral staircase leading to the crown of Lady Liberty (Click on photo to enlarge)

The fear of communism dominated the first ten years after WWII.  Republican control of Congress led to the witch-hunts for communists by the House Un-American Activities Committee and Joe McCarthy’s Senate sub-committee.  Movie actors, writers, and directors who were involved in movies depicting topics of anti-war, racism, or injustice in America were investigated. The Hollywood Ten went to prison and were blacklisted for refusing to testify. McCarthyism came to mean “guilt by association.” Since McCarthy never found a communist in colleges or in the state and defense departments, he destroyed his victims by connecting them to friends, acquaintances, publications, or organizations that were suspect. This relentless assault on the Bill of Rights was one of the darkest and scariest times for all our citizens.


David Offutt in front of the Great Hall at the Ellis Island National Museum of Immigration

David Offutt in front of the Great Hall at the Ellis Island National Museum of Immigration. Between 1892 and the 1920s, over 17 million immigrants passed through here and helped make America.






Prejudice against gays and lesbians has been a more recent example of a particular segment of our society being targeted for legalized discrimination. The Defense of Marriage Act, Don’t Ask – Don’t Tell, and anti-same-sex marriage amendments to state constitutions established restrictions to the rights of specific American citizens who posed no threat to others.


After 9/11, Vice President Dick Cheney, appropriately known as Darth Vader, publicly stated that our dark side was needed to deal with terrorism. He used our fear and hatred to justify the use of waterboarding, secret CIA sites in countries that would use torture, and indefinite imprisonment of suspected terrorists at Guantanamo.  The Bush-Cheney administration also used 950 documented lies to frighten the Congress and public into approving the invasion of Iraq.


All of the above are ostensibly against everything we claim to stand for: liberty and justice for all.


Ellis Island in front of the NYC skyline as seen from the pedestal of the Statue of Liberty (Click on the photo to enlarge)

Ellis Island in front of the NYC skyline as seen from the pedestal of the Statue of Liberty (Click on the photo to enlarge)

Now, because of ISIS, al-Qaida, Boko Haram, domestic terrorism, and the refugee flight from Syria, we see a backlash against Muslim-Americans and Muslims in general – not only against the bloodthirsty extremists. The game plan of ISIS is to get American leaders and their followers to target all Muslims’ rights so that ISIS looks better to other Muslims than we do.


Republican presidential candidates and 27 governors (26 Republicans and 1 Democrat) stampeded into panic mode by appealing to our dark side. Consequently, their Muslim xenophobia is reacting right into the hands of ISIS. Effectively, they are helping ISIS recruit more terrorists.



(Click on photos to enlarge)

(Click on photos to enlarge)

The 27 governors announced that they wanted no Syrian refugees relocated in their states. I’m sorry to say, this includes my state of Arkansas’s Asa Hutchinson. Marco Rubio thinks we should shut down all Muslim cafés and diners. He also has said that the fight against ISIS is a “clash of civilizations” –western civilization v. Islamic civilization. Jeb! Bush wants to restrict refugees to only those who are Christian. John Kasich wants to create a federal agency that will promote Judeo-Christian western values.


The worst, of course, are the two demagogues: Ted Cruz – who resembles Joe McCarthy – and Donald Trump – an apparent fascist who sounds like Hitler and, without the hair, would look like Mussolini. Sen. Cruz wants to carpet bomb Iraq and Syria with no regard for civilian casualties! The Donald wants to shut down U.S. mosques or at least place them under surveillance, require registration of our 3 million Muslims and require them to carry an ID denoting their religion, and prevent all Muslims from entering the country.


None of them are suggesting anything that might have a positive effect: (1) closing Guantanamo, which is a primary recruiting tool for terrorists and (2) making it illegal for those on the terrorist watch list to buy guns – between 2004 and 2014, 2000 suspects did so.


On the street level of most tenements were shops, eateries, and bars.

David Offutt (reflected) in front of the Lower East Side Tenement Museum: On the street level of most tenements were shops, eateries, and bars.

These governors and candidates have forgotten who we are and the diversity from which we come.  I suggest they do as I did last summer: Go to New York City. Take the ferry out to the Statue of Liberty. Read the poem by Emma Lazarus. Climb the narrow, spiral staircase to the crown (I took one step at a time, grabbing the rail with both hands and eventually pulling my way to the top). Re-board the ferry and get off at Ellis Island where millions of Americans can trace their ancestry. Visit the Lower East Side Tenement Museum and see how immigrants lived and worked (I took three different tours).


I also suggest they go see the new Star Wars: Episode VII – The Force Awakens. I know these presidential hopefuls and 27 governors probably rooted for Darth Vader and the dark side of the Force in the previous six installments, but, just maybe, they might be converted this time. Besides, since the original stars are back, this episode might even be as entertaining as the three original episodes were 30-40 years ago.

By David Offutt

A version of this essay was published December 11, 2015, in the El Dorado News-Times as a letter to the editor.


  1. Closing Gitmo? Obama has always had the authority to release the Gitmo prisoners, no congressional approval required. He has always had the authority to give them a fair trial, in which case they would have been found not guilty — even if they had been involved in Al Qaeda most of the evidence would have been thrown out because it had been obtained illegally. But it’s all Republican’s fault ?

    No mention of that other terrorist recruiting tool, Obama’s drone assassination program ???

    No mention of that other terrorist recruiting tool, the UniParty’s unflinching support for Israel ???

    No mention of that other terrorist recruiting tool, our military bases all over the world, supported by both parties ???

    The Bush-Cheney terrorist watch list, like Joe McCarthy’s witch hunt, is based on the presumption of guilt by association. What part of “innocent until proven guilty” do you not support, David?

    If I were an 11th grade history teacher, I might assign an essay question asking students to compare and contrast Joe McCarthy’s list to the Bush-Cheney-Obama list. I might even ask them to imagine what Edward R. Murrow would say about it. ;-)

    No mention of why Muslims are immigrating — because both Democrats and Republicans have acted to destabilized the Middle East. Obama and Hillary chose to destabilize Libya — how did that work out? Obama has continued the Bush policy of CIA support for regime change in Syria — how is that working out? Obama has supported the illegal Saudi invasion of Yemen. Obama has supported Turkey’s aggression against Syria and Iraq and Russia, bringing us dangerously close to WWIII — but it’s Donald Trump’s fault?

    Speaking of tracing our ancestry, some of my ancestors were Native American. How do you suppose Native Americans feel about immigration? How do you suppose Native Americans feel about the Statue of Liberty? If it were up to me we would let Native Americans vote on immigration policy and go along with whatever they decide. After all, it’s their country !

    It’s commendable to be concerned about the people from Syria, Libya, Latin America, and the other countries that we have destabilized, but maybe we should stop destabilizing those countries?

    I enjoy your vacation photos, as always. :-)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: